The Study of Religion and History • pp. 951-958
موقوف بحکمِ مرفوع کی اصولی و فقہی حیثیت: مفہوم، ضوابط، تطبیقی نمونے اور حجیت کا تنقیدی جائزہ: The Uṣūlī (Methodological) and Fiqhī (Jurisprudential) Status of Mawqūf bi-Ḥukm Marfū‘: A Critical Analysis of Its Concept, Criteria, Applied Examples, and Evidentiary Authority
Abstract
The classification of Prophetic traditions into Mawqūf (statements of Companions) and Marfū‘ (statements of the Prophet) is fundamental to Islamic jurisprudence. However, a significant methodological challenge arises when determining the Prophetic linkage of Mawqūf narrations that are deemed bi-Ḥukm Marfū‘ (having the ruling of a Marfū‘ report). This study critically examines the methodological and jurisprudential status of such narrations. It begins by establishing the linguistic and technical definitions of Mawqūf, Marfū‘, and Marfū‘ Ḥukmī, clarifying their foundational differences. The research then systematically delineates the primary criteria—known as Imārāt al-Raf‘ (indications of elevation)—employed by classical Muḥaddithīn to elevate a Mawqūf narration to the status of Marfū‘, such as a Companion stating actions they were commanded to do, explaining occasions of revelation, or reporting on unseen matters. The study applies these criteria to practical examples extracted from canonical Hadith collections, including Ṣaḥīḥ al-Bukhārī and Sunan Abī Dāwūd , illustrating the contextual operation of this legal presumption. Subsequently, the research probes the extent of jurisprudential authority these narrations possess. A critical analysis reveals that while Muḥaddithīn frequently utilize this mechanism to expand the Prophetic corpus, its evidentiary authority ( Ḥujjiyyah ) is predominantly ẓannī (speculative) rather than qaṭ‘ī (definitive), contingent upon the strength of contextual indicators. The study concludes that although these elevated narrations hold significant weight in deriving Islamic rulings, their application is bound by rigorous conditionalities. Ultimately, this research asserts that a nuanced understanding of this principle is vital for contemporary Islamic legal reasoning, preventing both the undue expansion and unjustified restriction of Prophetic guidance in the formulation of Sharī‘ah.
Record
- Identifier
- https://doi-services.com/1106/611
- Published
- 2026-03-24
- Version
- 1