DOI Services Persistent Identifiers for Scholarly Research
You are viewing the preserved copy. Open the article on the journal's website →

The Study of Religion and History • pp. 49-67

Human-Based and Gen-AI Academic Writing:A Comparative Linguistic Analysis of Cohesion and Coherence

  • Almeera Aimen
  • Fatima Zahid
  • Dr. Jahanzeb Jahan
  • Tariq Mahmood Tahir

Abstract

This research does a comparative linguistic analysis of cohesion and coherence in human generated and AI generated academic essays, using Halliday and Hassan's Cohesion theory and Charolles’ Coherence theory. With the rise of artificial intelligence, particularly big language model such as ChatGPT has intensified the interest in assessing the effectiveness ofAI in academic writing. This research examines 100 essays including 50 written by humans and 50 by artificial intelligence (ChatGPT) with an emphasis on the use of cohesive devices, additive adversative, causal and temporal conjunctions with anaphoric andcataphoric references, substitution, ellipsis and lexical choices , collocation and reiteration. This investigation reveals that while AI generated essays outperform in temporal conjunctions (65.79%) and cataphoric references (74.03%). But human writing exhibit more proficiency in additive conjunctions (64.12%) and anaphoric references (60.63%). Humans related articles exhibit more superior coherence, showcasing the complexity and depth in argumentation. In contrast, AI generated essays are more systematicand logically organized framework however lack the nuance development of concepts of human writing. The findings highlight the strength and limitations of AI in replicating human-like academic writing, suggesting areas for further enhancement in AI-assisted educational tools instruments and writing technology.

Record

Identifier
https://doi-services.com/1106/113
DOI
10.63163/555aja34
Published
2025-03-25
Version
1
Original
https://studentsconsultancyhome.com/srh-journal/index.php/srh/article/view/113