Qualitative Research Journal For Social Studies • pp. 262-290
The Status and Legal Authority of ʿUrf in Ḥanafī and Mālikī Jurisprudence: AComparative and Analytical Study
Abstract
The concept of ʿUrf (custom) occupies a significant position in Islamic jurisprudence as a
supplementary source for deriving legal rulings, particularly in matters where explicit textual
evidence is absent or requires contextual interpretation. This study presents a comparative and
analytical examination of the legal authority (ḥujjiyyah) of ʿUrf in the Ḥanafī and Mālikī schools
of Islamic law. It explores the definitions, classifications, evidential foundations, conditions of
validity, juristic maxims, and practical applications of ʿUrf in both schools. The research further
investigates the relationship between ʿUrf and other juristic principles, particularly Qiyās
(analogical reasoning), highlighting the circumstances in which customary practice is preferred
over analogical deduction. In addition, the study analyzes the role of ʿUrf in the specification of
general legal texts, the restriction of unrestricted rulings, and the resolution of contemporary legal
issues through practical examples drawn from commercial transactions, leases, wills, and family
law. Employing a comparative and qualitative methodology based on classical juristic sources,
the study demonstrates that both the Ḥanafī and Mālikī schools recognize valid custom as an
authoritative legal proof, although they differ in the scope and methodology of its application. The
findings reveal that ʿUrf serves as an essential mechanism for ensuring flexibility, facilitating legal
adaptation to changing social circumstances, and preserving the objectives of Sharīʿah while
maintaining fidelity to its foundational texts.
Keywords
Record
- Identifier
- https://doi-services.com/1105/1280
- Published
- 2026-03-30
- Version
- 1