DOI Services Persistent Identifiers for Scholarly Research
You are viewing the preserved copy. Open the article on the journal's website →

Journal of Applied Linguistics and Tesol • pp. 1521-1536

"EVALUATING THE ROLE OF AI TOOLS IN ENHANCING CRITICALTHINKING AND ARGUMENTATION IN HIGH-STAKES WRITING AMONGGRADUATE STUDENTS AT MUET HYDERABAD"

  • Ghulam Mustafa
  • Ali Raza Khoso
  • Muhammad Ahsan Raza

Abstract

The present study examined how Artificial Intelligence (AI) writing tools affect critical

thinking and argumentation abilities of 75 graduate students in Mehran University of

Engineering and Technology (MUET), Hyderabad, in high stake academic writing

situations including theses and assignments. The quantitative descriptive research design

was used to gather data through a structured questionnaire which was based on Philp and

Duchesne (2022) study, including Likert-scale and open-ended questions. Descriptive

statistics indicated that Grammarly (52.0%), ChatGPT (48.0%), and Quillbot (45.3%) are

widely used tools mainly to correct grammar (77.3%) and paraphrase (73.3%). Average

mean scores (2.95336) showed that there were few perceived benefits related to critical

thinking and argumentation, and more support was shown to the superficial correctness in

writing. The cross-tabulation indicated that the frequent AI users perceived more

improvements on idea generation and thesis clarity, whereas correlation analyses

established positive correlations between the frequency of use and critical thinking

(r=0.31, p<0.01) and argumentation (r=0.29, p<0.05). Open-ended responses thematic

analysis revealed generic feedback (45%) and a lack of creativity (30%) as the major

drawbacks, and 52% raised the possibility of AI integration with training. The results

indicate that AI-based technology can be used to improve mechanical writing, however, it

is limited when it comes to the development of higher-order skills, which requires the

assistance of human instructors. By highlighting the necessity of pedagogical approaches

toward balancing AI applications and critical approach to learning in Pakistani higher

education, the study provides a practitioner and policymaker insight.

Record

Identifier
https://doi-services.com/1104/810
DOI
10.0000/3vehew84
Published
2025-06-30
Version
1
Original
https://studentsconsultancyhome.com/jalt/index.php/jalt/article/view/810