Journal of Applied Linguistics and Tesol • pp. 2479-2502
Toxic Parenting, Educational Neglect and the Psychological Well-Being of Young Adults in Pakistan: A Secondary-Data Study in Comparative International Perspective
Abstract
Family relationships and educational environments are the two most proximal developmental systems in which psychological well-being is shaped. This article examines what is known about the relationship between two exposures—harmful parenting (operationalised through the measured constructs of parental psychological control, parental rejection, harsh and violent discipline, and emotional unavailability) and educational disadvantage in the family and school environment—and the psychological well-being of young adults in Pakistan, placing the Pakistani evidence in comparative international perspective. The study is a secondary-data, document-based synthesis. No primary data were collected. It integrates Pakistan's 7th Population and Housing Census (2023), the Pakistan Demographic and Health Survey (2017–18), provincial Multiple Indicator Cluster Surveys, the National Psychiatric Morbidity Survey of Pakistan (2022), Pakistan Education Statistics, the Pakistan Economic Survey (2024–25), and World Bank, UNESCO, WHO and UNICEF datasets, and reads these against the international parenting, adverse-childhood-experience (ACE) and adolescent mentalhealth literatures. Four conclusions are supported. First, Pakistan's population structure gives young-adult wellbeing unusual weight: 26 per cent of the population (62.58 million) is aged 15–29. Second, exposure to violent and psychologically aggressive discipline of children is high in the provinces and territories for which survey data exist: past-month prevalence of any violent discipline ranges from 55.3 to 85.0 per cent across four reporting rounds conducted between 2014 and 2020. Third, the education system is characterised by large-scale exclusion and low learning: 25– 26 million children aged 5–16 are out of school and 77–80 per cent of children are "learning poor." Fourth, measured psychological distress among young adults is high and system capacity is very low: pooled depressive-symptom prevalence among Pakistani university students is 42.7 per cent (95% CI 34.8–50.9), national current psychiatric morbidity is 32.28 per cent, and there are approximately 0.19 psychiatrists per 100,000 population. Two methodological cautions frame the entire analysis. First, the national education indicators used here—out-of-school counts, learning poverty, attrition, public expenditure—are structural measures of the education system, not measures of parental educational neglect. They are consistent with, but do not establish, family-level neglect, because they are also produced by poverty, school availability, distance, child labour, gender norms, displacement and government policy. Second, the design is cross-sectional, ecological and secondary; it cannot support causal claims about Pakistan. The article therefore reports associations, co-occurrence and theoretical plausibility, and states explicitly where the evidence runs out.
Keywords
Record
- Identifier
- https://doi-services.com/1104/3094
- Published
- 2026-03-29
- Version
- 1