Journal of Applied Linguistics and Tesol • pp. 22-29
A LINGUISTIC STUDY OF THE QURANIC WORDS “UMM AL-QURA”: REFUTING DAN GIBSON’S HAGARISM -BASED ARGUMENT
Abstract
This study critically examines Dan Gibson’s interpretation of the Qur’anic designation Umm al-Qurā and his rejection of its traditional identification with Mecca. Gibson argues that Umm al-Qurā denotes either a major urban centre or an ancient city and maintains that Mecca does not satisfy these criteria. He further argues that the alleged absence of archaeological remains predating the ninth century CE demonstrates that Mecca did not exist as an established city during the lifetime of the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ . This study evaluates these claims through a critical analysis of Qur’anic language, classical exegetical literature, Islamic historical tradition, and archaeological methodology. It demonstrates that the classical exegetical tradition offers multiple explanations for the designation of Mecca as Umm al-Qurā, emphasizing its religious, geographical, historical, and spiritual centrality rather than merely its physical size or antiquity. The study further argues that Gibson’s linguistic interpretation of umm as implying a large or ancient city does not adequately account for its broader semantic range and established usage in expressions such as Umm al-Kitāb and Umm al-Qur’ān. Regarding archaeology, the study contends that the absence of extensive pre-ninth-century remains from central Mecca cannot, by itself, establish the absence of an ancient settlement, particularly given continuous occupation, urban redevelopment, and restrictions on archaeological excavation. The comparison with Medina further raises questions concerning the consistency of Gibson’s archaeological methodology. The study concludes that Gibson’s reconstruction requires substantially broader engagement with textual, exegetical, historical, geographical, and archaeological evidence before the traditional identification of Mecca as Umm al-Qurā can be rejected.
Keywords
Record
- Identifier
- https://doi-services.com/1104/3081
- Published
- 2026-02-22
- Version
- 1