Journal of Applied Linguistics and Tesol • pp. 405-426
موقوف روایاتِ بحکمِ مرفوع سے استدلال کے اصول و مناہج: کتبِ حدیث کی روشنی میں ایک اختصاصی و تجزیاتی مطالعہ: Principles and Methodologies of Using Mawqūf Reports Deemed Marfūʿ as Evidence: A Specialized Analytical Study in the Light of Ḥadīth Literature
Abstract
This study examines the evidentiary status of mawqūf reports that, despite being formally attributed to a Companion, are treated by ḥadīth scholars as having the legal effect of marfūʿ reports. The research focuses on the principles and methodological indicators through which such reports are elevated in authority and used in juristic reasoning. Drawing primarily on ḥadīth literature and the discussions of leading muḥaddithūn and uṣūl scholars, the study analyzes the distinction between purely mawqūf reports and mawqūf reports that are marfūʿ in ruling. Particular attention is given to reports concerning matters beyond the scope of personal reasoning, statements connected explicitly with the Prophetic period, expressions such as “min al-sunnah,” anonymous forms of command and prohibition such as “umirnā” and “nuhīnā,” and reports indicating Prophetic approval through established practice during the lifetime of the Prophet ﷺ. The study also considers the role of contextual indicators, the Companion’s position, the possibility or impossibility of ijtihād, and the relationship of such reports with Qur’anic principles, established Sunnah, and broader rules of Sharīʿah. Selected examples from major ḥadīth collections are analyzed to demonstrate how the theoretical principles operate in practical inference. The findings show that the authority of mawqūf reports is not uniform; rather, it depends on identifiable textual and contextual criteria. When a report contains a reliable indication of Prophetic origin or concerns a matter inaccessible to independent reasoning, it may legitimately function as marfūʿ in legal argumentation. The study concludes that careful differentiation between ordinary mawqūf reports and those deemed marfūʿ is essential for accurate ḥadīth interpretation, sound legal deduction, and a balanced understanding of the evidentiary role of the Companions’ reports.
Record
- Identifier
- https://doi-services.com/1104/3037
- Published
- 2026-03-16
- Version
- 1