DOI Services Persistent Identifiers for Scholarly Research

Journal of Applied Linguistics and Tesol • pp. 426-446

SILENCES IN THE STORM: AN ECOLINGUISTIC ANALYSIS OF ERASURE IN THEENVIRONMENTAL NEWS HEADLINES OF PAKISTANI ENGLISH-LANGUAGENEWSPAPERS

  • Faiqa Waheed
  • Sheeza Khalid
  • Muhammad Shafqat Nawaz (Corresponding Author) Lecturer, Department of English Linguistic and Literature, Riphah International University, Sahiwal Campus, Punjab, Pakistan m.shafqat@riphahsahiwal.edu.pk

Abstract

When it comes to reporting floods, smog, locust swarms, earthquakes, heatwaves or stray-animal conflicts, Pakistani

newspapers keep relentlessly reporting the events but the language of the headline doesn't mention who suffers, who is

in charge or who is to be blamed. In this study, this absence was explored. Following Stibbe (2015), and especially the

notion of erasure and its three stages, the study has been based on twenty-nine environmental news headlines that have

been picked from English-language sources in Pakistan: twenty-six headlines from Dawn, one from The Express

Tribune, and two supplementary policy and archival texts. A qualitative, descriptive and interpretive design was used,

and each headline was explored in terms of the language/suppression/backgrounding of participants, the ecological

ideologies embedded in those language/suppressions and the amount to which that ideology could be accepted within

the stated ecosophy of interdependence, justice and ecological limits. The analysis, which confirmed that erasure was

not limited to occasional occurrences, revealed that nearly all headlines committed at least one type of erasure and

most undertook two or three. Through the processes of nominalisation, agentless and passive constructions, the

personification of nature as a destructive entity, the massification of animal and casualty, numerical abstraction and

superordinate economic categories, the vulnerable populations, non-human life, and institutional responsibility were

all backgrounded. The three conceptual groupings that emerged throughout the data were: economistic

anthropocentrism, where nature was important only as a means of production for markets; environmental determinism,

where the hazards were autonomous forces acting upon a helpless population; and technocratic managerialism, where

the crisis was a matter of administrative control, not of justice. The study concludes that the ecological harm headlines

in Pakistan not only record ecological harm but also erode accountability for it, while the study recommends a change

in the practice of headlines to restore the people, living things and responsible institutions to the sentence.

Record

Identifier
https://doi-services.com/1104/2586
DOI
10.66857/2586-be29
Published
2026-03-30
Version
1
Original
https://studentsconsultancyhome.com/jalt/index.php/jalt/article/view/2586