Contemporary Journal of Social Science Review • pp. 99-107
Protection of Fetal Rights in Islam and Sikhism: A Critical Engagement with Western Legal Discourse
Abstract
The question of fetal rights occupies a central yet contested position
in contemporary legal and ethical discourse. While Western legal
paradigms often frame the issue through the lens of individual
autonomy and reproductive choice, Islamic jurisprudence and Sikh
ethical thought articulate alternative frameworks grounded in the
sanctity of life and divine ontology. This study offers a comparative
analysis of fetal rights in Islam and Sikhism, critically engaging with
dominant Western legal narratives. Drawing upon the Qur’ān,
Hadith, classical Islamic jurisprudence (fiqh), and the Guru Granth
Sahib, the paper explores how both traditions conceptualize the moral
and ontological status of the unborn. The study argues that Islam
provides a structured juridical framework for fetal protection,
whereas Sikhism advances a spiritually grounded ethic of life dignity.
In contrast, Western legal discourse often reflects a rights-based
individualism that can marginalize the moral status of the unborn.
The article ultimately proposes a dialogical rethinking of fetal rights
that integrates legal rigor with ethical depth (An-Na’im, 2008; Cook,
2007).
Keywords
Record
- Identifier
- https://doi-services.com/1102/3554
- Published
- 2024-12-10
- Version
- 1