DOI Services Persistent Identifiers for Scholarly Research

Contemporary Journal of Social Science Review • pp. 1-26

اسلامی اور چینی تہذیب میں نظام حکمرانی اور عدل کا تقابلی مطالعہ:تاریخی و فکری تناظر میں : A Comparative Study of the Systems of Governance and Justice in Islamic and Chinese Civilizations: A Historical and Intellectual Perspective

  • Liaqat Ali Qadri Ph.D. scholar, Islamic Studies, NCBA&E Lahore.
  • Dr. Farooq Ali Assistant Professor, Department of Islamic Studies NCBA&E, DHA Campus, Lahore

Abstract

The system of governance and the concept of justice have played a fundamental role in the development, stability, and continuity of human civilizations. Islamic and Chinese civilizations represent two major and historically influential traditions that developed distinctive political, legal, ethical, and social systems over many centuries. This study presents a comparative analysis of the systems of governance and justice in Islamic and Chinese civilizations from historical and intellectual perspectives.

The study examines the fundamental principles of Islamic governance, including divine sovereignty, justice, consultation (Shura), trust, accountability, equality, and the rule of law. In Islamic civilization, governance is regarded as a responsibility and trust rather than merely a means of exercising political authority. The Qur'an emphasizes justice in governance and decision-making, while the Sunnah of the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) and the practices of the Rightly Guided Caliphs provide important practical examples of accountable and just governance. The development of institutions such as Qada (judiciary), Hisbah, and Mazalim further contributed to the institutionalization of justice in Islamic civilization.

In contrast, the Chinese system of governance developed through a combination of traditional political institutions and philosophical schools, particularly Confucianism and Legalism. Confucian political thought emphasized the moral character of the ruler, social harmony, ethical education, filial responsibility, and proper social relationships. Legalist thought, on the other hand, emphasized strong centralized authority, clearly defined laws, administrative control, and punishments as instruments for maintaining social order. The concept of the Mandate of Heaven also provided an important moral and political framework by linking the legitimacy of the ruler with his ability to govern responsibly and maintain social order.

The comparative analysis demonstrates that both civilizations attached considerable importance to the moral conduct of rulers, social stability, law, administrative organization, and the welfare of society. However, significant differences existed in their sources and foundations. Islamic governance was fundamentally rooted in divine revelation, Islamic law, moral accountability before Allah, and the concept of justice as a religious obligation, whereas traditional Chinese governance was largely shaped by philosophical ethics, imperial institutions, bureaucratic administration, and the principle of social harmony.

The study concludes that although Islamic and Chinese civilizations developed within different religious, philosophical, and historical contexts, both produced sophisticated traditions of governance and justice. Their comparative study provides valuable insights into the relationship between political authority, morality, law, accountability, and social justice. The research also suggests that a balanced understanding of these historical experiences can contribute to contemporary discussions concerning good governance, institutional accountability, justice, and social stability.

Record

Identifier
https://doi-services.com/1102/3519
DOI
10.66857/ba15qs49
Published
2025-03-13
Version
1
License
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0
Original
https://studentsconsultancyhome.com/contemporary-journal/index.php/cjssr/article/view/3519