Contemporary Journal of Social Science Review • pp. 1-9
علل الحدیث میں متن، سند اور تاریخی سیاق کا باہمی تعامل: منتخب نقدی فیصلوں کا تجزیاتی مطالعہ: The Interaction of Text, Chain of Transmission, and Historical Context in ‘Ilal al-Hadith: An Analytical Study of Selected Critical Judgments
Abstract
This study investigates the science of ʿilal al-ḥadīth, the discipline concerned with the hidden defects that undermine the authenticity of a report whose outward form appears sound, and analyses the interaction among three analytical axes: the text (matn), the chain of transmission (isnād) and the historical context (siyāq tārīkhī). It begins with a conceptual clarification of the term ʿilla, following the definition of Ibn al-Ṣalāḥ, and surveys the principal works of the genre, from Ibn Abī Ḥātim and al-Dāraquṭnī to Ibn Rajab. The methodological core of the discipline, namely the collation of all routes of a report (jamʿ al-ṭuruq) and the comparison of narrators, is then examined through the statement of ʿAlī b. al-Madīnī preserved by al-Khaṭīb al-Baghdādī. The second half of the article analyses five selected critical judgments: the confusion between ʿAmr b. Dīnār and ʿAbd Allāh b. Dīnār in the ḥadīth on the option of the two parties to a sale; the criticism of Sharīk b. ʿAbd Allāh’s account of the Night Journey; the dispute between Ibn ʿUmar and ʿĀʾisha over the ʿumra of Rajab; the conflicting reports on the marriage of Maymūna during iḥrām; and ʿĀʾisha’s corrections of Companions’ reports as collected by al-Zarkashī. The disagreement between Muslim and al-Bukhārī on narrator contact (liqāʾ and muʿāṣara) shows how historical knowledge operates within isnād criticism. The study then engages with Goldziher, Schacht, Juynboll, Motzki and Brown, and with the response of al-Aʿẓamī, in order to assess the claim that early critics neglected matn criticism. Following a thesis, evidence, counter-argument and synthesis structure, it argues that ʿilal judgments cannot be reduced to isnād or matn analysis alone, but emerge from an integrated, comparative and historically informed assessment whose indications (qarāʾin) are probabilistic rather than mechanical. It concludes by proposing a five-stage framework for contemporary scholarly application and critical practice today.
Keywords
Record
- Identifier
- https://doi-services.com/1102/3518
- Published
- 2026-03-10
- Version
- 1