DOI Services Persistent Identifiers for Scholarly Research

Contemporary Journal of Social Science Review • pp. 226-232

ANCIENT CARTOGRAPHY AND THE HISTORICAL IDENTITY OF MAKKAH: A CRITICAL EXAMINATION OF DAN GIBSON'S CLAIMS

  • Nisar Ahmad PhD Scholar, Department of Islamic & Arabic Studies University of Swat Email: nisarkabal123@gmail.com Orcid ID: https://orcid.org/0009-0008-6538-6748
  • Dr. Muhammad Dawood Khan Lecturer, Department of Islamic Studies , Bacha Khan University, Charsadda Email ID: muhammaddawoodkhan749@gmail.com
  • Maseeh Ullah M.Phil Scholar, Department of Islamic & Religious Studies, Hazara University, Manshera Email ID: maseehullah236@gmail.com

Abstract

The historical identity and antiquity of Makkah have become central issues in contemporary revisionist

scholarship on the origins of Islam. Among the most influential proponents of this approach, Dan Gibson

argues that Petra, rather than Makkah, was the original sacred city of Islam and that Makkah did not

emerge as an inhabited and religiously significant centre until the late first Islamic century. His

reconstruction relies primarily on the alleged absence of Makkah from two ancient cartographic sources:

Ptolemy's Geographia and the Madaba Mosaic Map. This article critically evaluates the historical and

methodological validity of this argument through a contextual analysis of these two maps and the wider

body of relevant historical evidence. The study demonstrates that Ptolemy's geographical account is

characterised by substantial cartographic inaccuracies arising from methodological limitations, reliance

on second-hand information, and systematic errors in the calculation of latitude and longitude. It further

argues that the geographical discrepancy between Makoraba and present-day Makkah cannot reasonably

be regarded as evidence against their identification. Likewise, the Madaba Map is shown to be a regional

representation of the Holy Land and its surrounding biblical landscape rather than a comprehensive map

of the Arabian Peninsula. Consequently, the omission of Makkah from this map carries no historical or

methodological significance. The article also examines references to Makkah preserved in Greco-Roman,

Assyrian, and Egyptian literary traditions and identifies significant internal inconsistencies within

Gibson's own reconstruction, particularly concerning the alleged transfer of the Kaʿbah from Petra to

Makkah. The study concludes that Gibson's thesis is founded upon a selective interpretation of

cartographic evidence, methodological weaknesses, and internally inconsistent arguments. When the

available cartographic, literary, and historical evidence is examined within its proper historical context,

it does not support the claim that Makkah was absent or historically insignificant before the ninth century

CE. Instead, the cumulative evidence strongly supports the historical antiquity and enduring religious

significance of Makkah in early Islamic history

Record

Identifier
https://doi-services.com/1102/3507
DOI
10.66857/ysy6a195
Published
2025-06-30
Version
1
License
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0
Original
https://studentsconsultancyhome.com/contemporary-journal/index.php/cjssr/article/view/3507