Contemporary Journal of Social Science Review • pp. 223-237
A CRITICAL EXAMINATION OF IGNAZ GOLDZIHER'S ALLEGATION OF HADITH FABRICATION AGAINST IMAM AL-ZUHRĪ
Abstract
This study critically examines the allegations made by the renowned Orientalist Ignaz Goldziher against
Imām Muḥammad ibn Muslim al-Zuhrī (d. 124 AH), one of the most distinguished transmitters and early
compilers of Prophetic ḥadīth. Goldziher, in his seminal work Muhammedanische Studien, accused alZuhrī of fabricating ḥadīths to serve the political interests of the Umayyad caliphs, particularly ʿAbd alMalik ibn Marwān. Employing a critical and analytical methodology, this paper evaluates Goldziher's
claims by consulting authentic biographical sources, the evaluations of al-Jarḥ wa al-Taʿdīl scholars, and
established historical records. The study demonstrates that Goldziher's accusations rest upon multiple
scholarly errors: a fundamental misreading of al-Zuhrī's statement regarding the writing of ḥadīths,
confusion between kitābat al-ḥadīth (transcription) and waḍʿ al-ḥadīth (fabrication), reliance on a
historically unreliable narration from Tārīkh al-Yaʿqūbī, and a disregard for chronological evidence—
particularly that al-Zuhrī's first meeting with ʿAbd al-Malik occurred in 82 AH, nearly a decade after the
alleged fabrication period. The study further establishes that the hadith cited by Goldziher as evidence is
transmitted through numerous independent chains by multiple contemporaries of al-Zuhrī, confirming its
authenticity. The unanimous testimonies of ḥadīth critics, including Imām Aḥmad ibn Ḥanbal, Imām alNasāʾī, and Imām al-Dhahabī, affirm al-Zuhrī's integrity, reliability, and scholarly authority. The paper
concludes that Goldziher's allegations stem from a preconceived orientalist paradigm rather than
objective scholarship, and that Imām al-Zuhrī remains one of the most trustworthy preservers of the
Prophetic Sunnah in Islamic intellectual history.
Keywords
Record
- Identifier
- https://doi-services.com/1102/3506
- Published
- 2025-03-24
- Version
- 1