Contemporary Journal of Social Science Review • pp. 199-221
ERP SELECTION CRITERIA AND FINANCIAL AUTOMATION OUTCOMES IN EMERGING MARKET ORGANIZATIONS: TOWARDS A PRACTICAL SELECTION FRAMEWORK
Abstract
Enterprise resource planning systems sit at the centre of the modern finance function, yet the question of how
organisations in emerging markets should choose between them remains poorly answered. This study develops
and empirically evaluates a finance-led ERP selection framework for emerging market organisations. The
framework pairs the technology-organisation-environment framework, used to sort selection criteria into three
groups, with the DeLone and McLean model of information systems success, whose net-benefits construct is
re-specified as five financial automation outcomes: reporting accuracy and timeliness, auditability and
controls, IFRS and regulatory compliance, process automation, and total cost of ownership. Primary data
were collected through a structured questionnaire completed by 45 finance and technology professionals with
direct ERP experience, drawn mainly from Pakistan and other emerging markets. The instrument proved
reliable, with a Cronbach's alpha of 0.909 for the selection criteria scale and 0.867 for the outcomes scale.
Respondents rated data security and access control (mean 4.67), information quality (4.62) and adequacy of
finance and IT resources (4.58) as the most important selection criteria, and technological and organisational
items filled the entire top ten. All five outcomes were rated highly important, but clear gaps separated
importance from delivery, with the largest for process automation (0.54) and accurate and timely reporting
(0.51), and the smallest for IFRS and regulatory compliance (0.05). Results from multiple regression revealed
that the technology criteria were significantly predicted the importance of respondents considered the
financial automation results to be (β = 0.506, p = .011). On the other hand, the environment criteria
significantly predicted the achievement of the outcomes (β = 0.510, p = .005). The results support the
framework's propositions: expectations of ERP are shaped by technology, but what an organisation actually
collects is governed by its environment, consistent with the emerging-market context acting as a boundary
condition on realised success. The study contributes a practical, evidence-grounded selection tool for financeled organisations and extends information systems success research by giving the net-benefits construct a
concrete, measurable financial form.
Keywords
Record
- Identifier
- https://doi-services.com/1102/3433
- Published
- 2026-06-17
- Version
- 1