Contemporary Journal of Social Science Review • pp. 325-333
POLICING, LAW, AND JUSTICE: A CRIMINOLOGICAL ANALYSIS OF MURDER AND RIOTING THROUGH A FAISALABAD FIR CASE STUDY
Abstract
This study explores the intersection of law, policing, and justice by analyzing the legal dimensions of murder
and rioting in Pakistan through a qualitative case study of a First Information Report (FIR) registered in
Faisalabad. It addresses three key questions: (1) How does the FIR frame the charges of murder and
rioting? (2) What legal provisions of the Pakistan Penal Code (PPC) are invoked? and (3) What procedural
and legal challenges emerge during investigation and prosecution? Despite extensive doctrinal work on
murder and rioting offences, a significant gap exists in Pakistani criminological literature connecting
statutory provisions with field-level practices, including FIR drafting, police investigation, forensic
limitations, and witness protection deficits. To bridge this gap, the study employs a combined doctrinal and
document-analysis approach, integrating statutory law, judicial precedents, and secondary literature with
the examined FIR. Thematic coding identifies how the charges are framed, comparative analysis evaluates
congruence with statutory and judicial standards, and doctrinal interpretation examines whether laws are
properly applied or misused. Findings reveal that the FIR correctly invokes Sections 302, 148, and 149 of
the PPC, establishing both individual and collective liability; however, difficulties persist in proving
collective intent and distinguishing the roles of accused persons. While overall legal alignment is observed,
investigative shortcomings—particularly in forensic application and evidence collection—undermine
procedural justice. The study concludes that ensuring prosecutorial effectiveness and fairness in complex
group-violence cases requires not only doctrinal clarity but also strengthening police investigative capacity,
evidentiary rigor, and witness protection systems to enhance justice outcomes within Pakistan’s criminal
justice framework.
Record
- Identifier
- https://doi-services.com/1102/3263
- Published
- 2025-10-06
- Version
- 1