DOI Services Persistent Identifiers for Scholarly Research

Contemporary Journal of Social Science Review • pp. 1077-1090

JUDICIAL ENDORSEMENT OF COUPS AND THE FRAGILITY OF DEMOCRACY IN PAKISTAN:AN ANALYSIS OF THE COURT-COUP NEXUS

  • Hafiza Anna Haq MPhil Scholar, Department of political science GCUFA.
  • Sadia Naz Lecture, Department of Political Science GCUF
  • Bushra Shaukat Lecturer, Department of Pakistan Studies, GCUF.

Abstract

Pakistan's political history has been marked by the judiciary's support of military takeovers, which has had a

significant impact on the stability and growth of the nation's democracy. In the past, Pakistan's Supreme Court

has frequently used the theory of state necessity which defends extra-constitutional actions as required to maintain

order and avert chaos to legitimize military takeovers. Beginning with the military takeover in 1958, this trend

has persisted through later interventions, such as those headed by Generals Pervez Musharraf in 1999 and Ziaul-Haq in 1977. In its historic decision supporting Musharraf's coup in 2000, the Supreme Court not only upheld

the military coup but also gave the military government the authority to change the constitution and rule during

the transitional period without parliamentary control. The rule of law and democratic governance in Pakistan

have been undermined by such court decisions, which have weakened civilian institutions, eroded constitutional

supremacy, and strengthened military influence in politics. The judiciary has frequently given up its independence

and constitutional mandate in order to maintain stability under military rule, which highlights the brittleness of

Pakistan's democracy. The judiciary has enabled a cycle of military interventions that undermine democratic

continuity and marginalize elected governments by supporting these coups. Further polarizing the political

landscape and eroding public trust in democratic institutions is the judiciary's involvement in politically

contentious cases, such as the disqualification of political leaders. A key element in maintaining authoritarianism

and impeding the consolidation of democracy in Pakistan has been the judiciary's compromised role, which is

highlighted by the frequent pattern of judicial approval of military takeovers

Record

Identifier
https://doi-services.com/1102/3223
DOI
10.66857/myzbnv92
Published
2025-10-05
Version
1
License
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0
Original
https://studentsconsultancyhome.com/contemporary-journal/index.php/cjssr/article/view/3223