DOI Services Persistent Identifiers for Scholarly Research

Contemporary Journal of Social Science Review • pp. 46-56

THE PUNISHMENT FOR A MARRIED ADULTERER AND ADULTERESS:STONING OR ONE HUNDRED LASHES A REVIEW OF MAULANA ISLAHI’SPOINT OF VIEW

  • Dr Imran Sajid
  • Dr. Muhammad Usman Khalid

Abstract

Amin Ahsan Islahi’s view on rajm departs fundamentally from the established Prophetic and juristic

understanding of Islamic criminal law. He argues that rajm was not a fixed legal punishment (ḥadd) for married

adulterers but a discretionary penalty imposed only on habitual offenders who posed a threat to social order. This

reinterpretation, however, lacks explicit textual support from the Sunnah. Authentic hadith literature consistently

shows that the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم treated marital status (iḥṣān) as the decisive legal criterion in cases of zinā. In several

rigorously authenticated narrations, the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم explicitly asked whether the accused was married before

determining the punishment. No report indicates that habitual criminality, public nuisance, or professional

immorality was investigated or treated as the legal cause of rajm. Islahi’s claim that Maʿiz b. Mālik was a habitual

offender is based on inference rather than clear evidence. The strong language used by the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم in certain

narrations serves as general admonition and deterrence for the community, not as a factual description of Maʿiz’s

character. Other authentic reports explicitly affirm the sincerity and عظمت of Maʿiz’s repentance, which

contradicts the notion of persistent criminal behavior. Furthermore, the absence of immediate supplication after

the execution does not indicate condemnation; it reflects a juridical context, as other narrations confirm that the

Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم later praised the repentance of those who were punished. In sum, Islahi’s theory redefines the legal

cause of rajm without prophetic precedent and stands in opposition to the consistent practice of the Prophet صلى الله عليه وسلم

and the unanimous understanding of the classical juristic tradition.

Record

Identifier
https://doi-services.com/1102/2068
DOI
10.66857/v7z1w219
Published
2026-03-11
Version
1
License
https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0
Original
https://studentsconsultancyhome.com/contemporary-journal/index.php/cjssr/article/view/2068