Contemporary Journal of Social Science Review • pp. 108-115
RESTORING THE BURDEN OF PROOF:CLARIFYING ATHEISM,THEISM,ANDAGNOSTICISM IN CONTEMPORARY DISCOURSE
Abstract
This paper critically examines the misuse of the "burden of proof" concept within contemporary atheist discourse,
focusing on influential figures such as Armin Navabi, Todd C. Moody, David Silverman, and Peter Boghossian.
Utilizing Shoaib Malik’s philosophical distinctions between ontological and epistemological claims, this analysis
challenges atheists’redefinition of atheism as merely "lack of belief" rather than an explicit denial of God's existence.
Such redefinitions, achieved through semantic fusion and morphological fission, allow atheists to evade evidentiary
responsibilities while implicitly advancing strong ontological assertions. By dissecting arguments from prominent
atheist voices, this paper demonstrates that agnosticism—not atheism—is the more appropriate default position in
the absence of compelling evidence. Furthermore, global atheism, characterized by its broad rejection of all deity
concepts, carries a significant but often overlooked epistemic burden. This study advocates restoring conceptual
clarity to the discourse on theism, atheism, and agnosticism, emphasizing intellectual consistency and accountability
Keywords
Record
- Identifier
- https://doi-services.com/1102/1060
- Published
- 2025-09-30
- Version
- 1