AL AASAR JOURNAL • pp. 67-78
نقدِ حدیث کی علمی و معرفتی بنیادیں: متقدمین اور متاخرین محدثین کے مناہج کا تقابلی مطالعہ: Epistemological Foundations of Hadith Criticism: A Comparative Study of the Methods of Early and Later Hadith Scholars
Abstract
This study investigates the epistemological foundations of hadith criticism through a comparative analysis of the methods of the early hadith critics (mutaqaddimūn) and the later scholars (mutaʾakhkhirūn). Hadith criticism is frequently portrayed either as a mechanical evaluation of chains of transmission or, in much Orientalist scholarship, as a late and ineffectual enterprise unconcerned with the content of reports. This article argues that both portrayals obscure a crucial historical development: the early critics, from Shuʿba and Yaḥyā al-Qaṭṭān to Aḥmad, Ibn al-Madīnī, al-Bukhārī and Abū Ḥātim al-Rāzī, practised a holistic, context-sensitive and case-by-case judgement grounded in the comparison of narrations and the weighing of circumstantial indicators (qarāʾin), whereas the later scholars, from al-Ḥākim and al-Khaṭīb to Ibn al-Ṣalāḥ and Ibn Ḥajar, codified this practice into systematic definitions and rules. Employing a historical, analytical and comparative methodology, the article first examines the Qurʾānic and Prophetic bases of transmission ethics and the epistemic categories of certainty (qaṭʿ) and probability (ẓann). It then compares the two approaches with regard to the criteria of authenticity, the addition by a reliable narrator, the conflict between connected and disconnected chains, the notion of the good (ḥasan) report, and the possibility of authenticating reports in later ages. Drawing on classical sources such as Muslim, al-Tirmidhī, Ibn Abī Ḥātim, Ibn al-Ṣalāḥ, Ibn Rajab and Ibn Ḥajar, and on modern scholarship including Brown, Dickinson, Motzki, Juynboll, Hallaq and al-Malībārī, the study also evaluates the Western critique of the isnād. It concludes that the difference between the two groups lies in epistemic method rather than in confidence in the sources, that codification brought precision but also the risk of formalism, and that contemporary scholarship should integrate the contextual judgement of the early critics with the clarity of later rules.
Keywords
Record
- Identifier
- https://doi-services.com/1101/2182
- Published
- 2026-03-19
- Version
- 1