AL AASAR JOURNAL • pp. 11-23
عرف کے تغیر اور فتویٰ کی تبدیلی: جنوبی ایشیا کے منتخب فقہی فتاویٰ کا تقابلی مطالعہ: Changing Custom and the Adaptation of Fatwa: A Comparative Study of Selected Juristic Opinions in South Asia
Abstract
This study examines how changing custom ('urf) has shaped the revision of fatwas in South Asia through a comparative analysis of selected juristic opinions. Starting from the classical principle, articulated by al-Qarafi, Ibn al-Qayyim, and Ibn 'Abidin, that rulings grounded in custom vary with custom while the underlying textual evidence remains constant, the paper asks how, and within what limits, South Asian muftis from the Deobandi and Barelwi traditions have applied this principle in the modern period. Three case studies structure the analysis: the permissibility of remuneration for teaching the Qur'an and leading prayer, where later Hanafi jurists departed from the early position after public stipends disappeared; the juristic treatment of paper currency, where the notion of money shifted from intrinsic to conventional value while the prohibition of riba was retained; and the dissolution of marriage for women whose husbands are missing or neglectful, where Ashraf 'Ali Thanawi's al-Hila al-Najiza drew on Maliki opinions and stands in the background of the Dissolution of Muslim Marriages Act of 1939. Employing a descriptive, analytical, and comparative method, and a thesis, evidence, counterargument, and synthesis structure, the study distinguishes between a change of ruling and a change in the application of an unchanged ruling, and identifies three recurrent safeguards: confinement of change to rulings founded on custom, verification that the new custom is sound and consistent with the objectives of the shari'a, and the presence of genuine necessity or hardship. The paper also addresses the objections that custom invites expediency and that muftis, as followers of a school, cannot depart from its positions. It concludes that the South Asian fatwa tradition has treated custom as a disciplined instrument of adaptation rather than an independent source of legislation, and recommends systematic documentation of custom, collective deliberation, and transparent reasoning in fatwa institutions.
Keywords
Record
- Identifier
- https://doi-services.com/1101/2178
- Published
- 2025-03-10
- Version
- 1