AL AASAR JOURNAL • pp. 1525-1543
منتخب مفسرین کے اصول ربط و نظم ایک تقابلی مطالعہ: Principles of Coherence and Arrangement in Selected Quranic Exegetes A Comparative Study
Abstract
This article compares the principles of Quranic coherence discussed in the supplied thesis on Muhammad Husayn Nilawi and Ali Ahmad Sandilwi, while also considering the Farahi and Islahi approaches where the thesis introduces them. The study seeks to distinguish shared commitments to connected interpretation from differences in the identification of central themes, the arrangement of surahs, and the use of contextual evidence. Its method is descriptive, comparative, and analytical. The comparison is organised around the unit of interpretation, the central purpose of a surah, relationships between adjacent passages, larger thematic divisions, and the status of exegetical conclusions. Particular attention is paid to the distinction between the coherence of the Quran itself and the fallibility of a commentator's proposed account of that coherence. The findings indicate that agreement on Quranic unity does not entail agreement on every structural division or interpretive relationship. Similarly, variation among commentators does not by itself invalidate a particular reading; competing proposals must be assessed through linguistic evidence, contextual fit, explanatory scope, and compatibility with established sources. The source thesis contains observations that support comparison but also includes broad evaluative claims and inconsistent formulations that require qualification. Consequently, the article avoids treating reported claims of completeness or certainty as independently established findings. It proposes a balanced procedure that begins with the text, identifies the relevant question, tests alternative relationships, and states the degree of interpretive confidence. The study concludes that comparative attention to these approaches can strengthen Quranic understanding when methodological diversity is combined with evidential discipline.
Record
- Identifier
- https://doi-services.com/1101/2153
- Published
- 2026-03-30
- Version
- 1