AL AASAR JOURNAL • pp. 1389-1398
EXTRA-JUDICIAL PUNISHMENTS: A SHARIAH, LEGAL, AND SOCIALANALYSIS OF KILLING, IMPRISONMENT, ENFORCED DISAPPEARANCE,AND ENCOUNTER KILLINGS
Abstract
This research presents a comprehensive analytical study of extra-judicial punishments prevalent in
contemporary Pakistani society, including extra-judicial killings, unlawful imprisonment, enforced
disappearances, and police encounter killings. The study examines these practices through the lenses of Islamic
Shariah, constitutional law, and their social implications. The research argues that extra-judicial punishments
fundamentally contradict the Islamic principles of justice, due process, and the presumption of innocence, which
require that no person be punished without clear evidence, proper judicial proceedings, and the right to
defense. Similarly, the Constitution of Pakistan guarantees fundamental rights including the right to life, liberty,
and fair trial, which are systematically violated by extra-judicial measures. The study analyzes the doctrine
of "al-asl bara'at al-dhimmah" (the principle that every person is presumed innocent until proven guilty) and
the Qur'anic emphasis on tathabbut (verification) and bayyinah (clear evidence) as foundational Islamic
principles that prohibit punishment without proof. It also critiques the recent Anti-Terrorism Amendment Bill
2025, which expands preventive detention powers, arguing that such laws undermine judicial oversight and
create opportunities for abuse. The study highlights the negative social consequences of extra-judicial
punishments, including erosion of public trust in the justice system, increased social fragmentation, and the risk
of targeting innocent individuals. It also acknowledges the public frustration with the slow and corrupt judicial
system that drives support for extra-judicial actions. The research concludes that sustainable peace and justice
can only be achieved through strengthening the formal judicial system, ensuring accountability, and adhering to
the Islamic and constitutional principles of justice, fairness, and due process.
Keywords
Record
- Identifier
- https://doi-services.com/1101/2028
- Published
- 2026-03-12
- Version
- 1