AL AASAR JOURNAL • pp. 267-1278
REASSESSING WILĀYAHAND WOMEN'S LEGAL CAPACITY IN ISLAMIC LAW: A CONTEMPORARY REAPPRAISAL OF CLASSICAL JURISPRUDENCE
Abstract
This article critically reappraises the classical doctrine of wilāyah(guardianship) and its implications for women's legal capacity in Islamic jurisprudence within contemporary legal and social contexts. It examines the conceptual foundations of wilāyah, its objectives, classifications, and historical evolution, alongside the divergent positions of the four Sunni schools of law concerning women's legal personality, marriage, property rights, and financial autonomy. Employing a qualitative doctrinal methodology based on primary Islamic sources and contemporary scholarship, the study distinguishes between immutable Sharīʿah principles and historically contingent juristic interpretations. The analysis demonstrates that while classical jurists generally conceived guardianship as a protective institution aimed at safeguarding individual welfare and social order, significant differences existed regarding the extent of women's independent legal authority. The study argues that many restrictions traditionally associated with women's legal capacity reflected specific historical and social circumstances rather than universally binding legal norms. Reinterpreting these rulings in light of the higher objectives (maqāṣid) of Sharīʿah—including justice, human dignity, welfare, and the prevention of harm—supports a more contextual understanding of wilāyahthat affirms women's independent legal personality and substantial legal and financial capacity. The article contributes to contemporary Islamic legal discourse by demonstrating how fidelity to Islamic legal principles can be harmonized withevolving constitutional, legal, and social realities without compromising the normative objectives of Sharīʿah.
Keywords
Record
- Identifier
- https://doi-services.com/1101/1982
- Published
- 2026-03-23
- Version
- 1