AL AASAR JOURNAL • pp. 642-652
A Critical Evaluation of Amina Wadud’s Feminist Hermeneutics in Quranic Exegesis
Abstract
This study provides a critical evaluation of Dr. Amina Wadud’s feminist hermeneutical approach to Quranic interpretation, as articulated in Qur’an and Woman (1999). It examines her methodological departures from classical Islamic exegesis, including the historicization of Quranic rulings, reinterpretation of gender roles, marginalization of Hadith authority, and reconstruction of foundational concepts such as qawwamah, hijab, and legal testimony. Using a comparative framework, the analysis contrasts Wadud’sfeminist readings with established principles of Islamic exegesis, which emphasize textual fidelity, adherence to prophetic tradition, and scholarly consensus (ijma).The findings indicate that Wadud’s approach relativizes immutable Quranic ordinances, negates divinely ordained distinctions between men and women, diminishes the role of prophetic guidance, and introduces external ideological frameworks into the text. Consequently, her hermeneutics disrupt the epistemological foundations of classical Islamic exegesis by weakening the integral connection between revelation, Prophetic explanation, and interpretive methodology. The study concludes that while feminist engagement with scripture raises important contemporary questions, Wadud’s interpretive model remains largely incompatible with mainstream Islamic orthodoxy and lacks methodological legitimacy within the classical exegetical tradition
Record
- Identifier
- https://doi-services.com/1101/1842
- Published
- 2026-03-23
- Version
- 1