AL AASAR JOURNAL • pp. 1374-1386
Modern Challenges Faced by the Judicial System: Causes,Impacts, and Remedies in the Light of the Prophetic Modelof Justice and Judiciary
Abstract
This analytical study examines the multifaceted challenges confronting modern judicial
systems worldwide including political interference, corruption, institutional fragility,
procedural delays, access to justice deficits, and the erosion of public trust through the
lens of the Prophetic model of justice and judiciary. Drawing upon the Seerah of
Prophet Muhammad صلى الله عليه وسلم, the research reconstructs the foundational principles that
underpinned the judicial system of the early Islamic state: impartiality, equality before
the law, the presumption of innocence, evidentiary rigor, appellate review, and the
integration of ethical and spiritual values into legal adjudication. Contemporary
scholarship on judicial independence, democratic backsliding, and rule of law crises is
analyzed alongside Prophetic traditions and Quranic injunctions. The study identifies
that modern judicial crises often stem from the same root causes the Prophetic model
addressed: concentration of power, lack of accountability, social inequality, and the
separation of law from morality. The Prophetic system employed flexible yet principled
methods of dispute resolution including confession (iqrar), evidence (bayyinah), oath
(yamin), collective oath (qasamah), judicial intuition (firasah), and mediation (sulh).
The study concludes with eight findings and six actionable recommendations for
reforming modern judicial systems through the integration of Prophetic ethical
principles
Keywords
Record
- Identifier
- https://doi-services.com/1101/1800
- Published
- 2025-06-30
- Version
- 1